Judith Biddington (left) receiving her Award of Merit from Richard Broome
On Tuesday 21 May 2019 Dr Judith Biddington, founder and inaugural president of the Carlton Community History Group (CCHG), was presented with of an Award of Merit by the Royal Historical Society of Victoria for "meritorious service" to a historical society. Thirteen years ago, Judith identified the need for a local community history group in Carlton and set about to achieve this goal. She placed a notice in the Carlton Library and this lead to the established a pattern of monthly meetings with presentations by people with some light to shed on the experience of growing up and living and working in Carlton. Within a year the Carlton Community History Group was meeting regularly, became incorporated, and achieved affiliation to the Royal Historical Society of Victoria.
From the start her approach has been to engage with local people directly, including shopkeepers, teachers, potential speakers for meetings, long term residents, representatives of organisations like churches and our local mosque, gathering history on the ground, and most importantly, involving and enthusing people. Along with several other hard working and dedicated members, Judith began recording a series of interviews with present and former Carlton residents. These oral histories are now to be digitised and made more accessible. She also began a series of special events and regular publications produced by the CCHG, commencing with her own booklet "Some Women of Davis Street : 1891 and 2008". Judith edited Des Norman's book "Through the eyes of a child : A street in Carlton 1939-45 and contributed a chapter to CCHG's latest publication "Carlton Voices", launched in October 2018.
Judith has also written several articles and book reviews for the CCHG website and these reflect her eclectic range of interests.
The Bassos of North Carlton : A Love Story and a Full Life
Betty Burstall 1926-2013
Carlton Footballers Who Fought and Died in the Wars
A Russian Visitor : Aleksandr Leonidovich Yashchenko
The Trades Hall : Part of our History
Vale Des Norman 1930-2015
Women and War : Two Case Studies
Gastronomia Dal 1953
The 2019 auction of the Enoteca Sileno at the southern end of Amess Street, North Carlton, breaks one more link with the heyday of Italian Carlton in the 1950s and 1960s, but at the same time highlights the way in which so many different aspects of Italian culture have been adapted to, and merged with, the Australian mainstream. Amess Street has always been mostly residential but this double-fronted building at nos. 21-3 is an exception.
As early as 1897 it appears in Sands & McDougall's business directory as Condon's woodyard, conveniently situated with lanes beside and behind it. Within a few years it had become Condon's dairy and remained so for almost fifty years. No cardboard cartons or glass bottles then. Milk was bought as required and carried home, often by children, in a billy. Jack Ward, who as a child in the 1940s lived just round the corner in Fenwick Street, helped out at Condon's after school by rolling the milk cans up the bluestone lane. He was paid in milk. After 1947 the dairy changed its name several times. For a while it was called the Princes Park Dairy, which was where local cows were sent to graze, returning down Amess Street and entering no. 21 through its big front doors. They were milked at the back of the building where the two last rooms have a concrete floor and a slope to facilitate washing down.
By the late 1950s the dairy had closed and the front room was rented by Italian migrant Luigi "Gino" Di Santo who arrived in Australia in 1952. With an extensive background in business and a long family history in wine and food he quickly saw the potential in Australia for Italian products. In 1953 he was the first Italian immigrant to have a stand at the Home Show in the Melbourne Exhibition Building displaying a Borletti portable sewing machine, Venetian glass from Murano and Italian cigars and cigarettes. The importing business quickly diversified into baby food, mineral water, preserved vegetables, olive oil, balsamic vinegar, wines and liqueurs, featuring goods in demand with the booming Italian population and previously unknown to Australians but soon to become popular.
As the business grew, Gino rented more and more of the space. It became a large-scale operation. His daughter Rosemary remembers that:
"We used to unload shipping containers, with our imports, which were diagonally parked on the road occupying more than half of the street with rollers sending down cartons into the building. These cartons were unloaded using conveyor rollers and ferried throughout the building on trolleys racing up and down the corridors into the appropriate storage spot. The containers were hand unloaded there for about 20 years. Before containers many shipments were brought to Australia in wooden crates."
21 Amess Street served other purposes as well. At one point newly-arrived Italian men were renting sleeping space at the back of the building and the dairy cool store was converted into a shower room. There was also a jam factory at the back of the building run by a Mrs Hoult. No. 23 was gradually incorporated into the main space, housing offices and providing additional storage. The facade had been renovated by the then owners, who also owned number no. 19, and who probably also added the concrete slab outside the front door; Ferdinando Busatta was a concreter by trade. The bluestone foundations of the original cast-iron fence can still be seen beneath the slab.
By the early 1980s the business was gradually changing its focus to more traditional artisan products and in 1982 Gino was able, as he had always wanted, to open a retail store, an enoteca or wine bar. His is thought to have been the first place in Australia to specialise in Italian wines and the first business to use the word enoteca in its name. Customers came from far and wide and many still remember the cluttered treasure house of goods it offered.
Gino had owned the building since 1986 but by 2004 Enoteca Sileno was ready for another major change, moving to a two storey corner building in Lygon Street, previously the Rising Sun Hotel, where today, under the proud banner Gastronomia dal 1953, it conducts wholesale and retail businesses with a wide range of Italian products as well as a cooking school. No. 21-23 Amess Street reverted to its original function as storage space until it was sold in October 2019. Many will be pleased that this historic building appears to have dodged the developer's bulldozer. The new owner intends to live there.
Information for this story has been sourced from the Enoteca Sileno website, with additional research by CCHG. The assistance of Rosemary Di Santo-Portelli is gratefully acknowledged.
Another Business Closes in Rathdowne Street
The Feathered Arbour
430 Rathdowne Street, North Carlton
The Feathered Arbour has closed in February 2019, with the expiry of the lease at its business premises. The building at 430 Rathdowne Street, North Carlton, home to the Feathered Arbour for the past six years, was once owned by motor mechanic Martin Shelley, who also operated his business at 420 and 520-522 Rathdowne Street.
Farewell to Mangala
Image: Courtesy of Mangiamele Family
Dorotea Mangiamele at Mangala
The atmosphere at the recent annual production by the Mangala Studios of Yoga and Creative Dance was reassuringly familiar. The theatre was packed with family supporters looking forward to another evening of quirky entertainment. Paper lanterns were laid out in the foyer for the usual just-after-dark walk through adjacent parkland. Peter Hockey was at the microphone, ready to narrate the storyline which would draw together the dances of a wide range of age groups. The youngest dancers were still at that age where they couldn't resist the temptation to rush to the edge of the stage and peer into the audience, looking for their parents so that they could wave to them. The oldest performers, some of them 19 or 20, took an altogether cooler approach, as one would expect of veterans of, in some cases, ten such productions. But the familiarity fell away when the performance finished and Peter announced that it had been the 37th - and the last. After almost 50 years at the corner of Grattan and Lygon Streets, Mangala is leaving Carlton and restructuring. Parking and traffic problems are part of the reason. Sadly, this move comes at the same time as the loss of another local institution, the Lygon Food Store, just a few minutes away.
The success of this dance studio over so many years with students of all ages can be ascribed to its very relaxed approach. Yoga forms an integral part of the program for older students and the emphasis is on individual responses to music, not on the learning of rigid routines. No pointe shoes here! Everyone dances bare-footed. Today the studio is run by Peter and Sue Hockey and Claudia Mangiamele. Peter also offers tuition in Tai Chi. The women, now in their sixties, are daughters of Dorotea Mangiamele, who founded the school in 1970, and have been involved with it since they were teenagers. They have another important link to Carlton. Their father was Giorgio Mangiamele, a popular family photographer for Italian families in the 1960s and 1970s, but more importantly director of a number of ground-breaking films dealing with the experience of Italian migrants. The best known of these, Clay, was chosen to compete at the Cannes film festival in 1965.
Related Item: The Side Window
The End of an Era for Community Health in Carlton
622 and 624 Lygon Street, North Carlton
Former Home of Carlton Community Health Centre
The Carlton Community Health Centre closed in November 2018, bringing to an end 39 years of community service. The centre first opened its doors on 1 October 1979 in a pair of terrace houses at 622 and 624 Lygon Street, North Carlton, near Princes Street. During the intervening years, the health centre has seen changes in the demography of its client base and the delivery of services, within the broader context of administrative, political and social changes. North Carlton was originally part of the City of Melbourne, but the reorganisation of municipal boundaries in the 1990s saw the service transferred to City of Yarra. The Carlton, Collingwood and Fitzroy Community Centres amalgamated as North Yarra Community Health (NYCH) in 1994.
As with many enforced amalgamations, the three centres did not always work together in harmony, and Carlton had its own problems with administration and internal politics. Missionaries, Radicals, Feminists, written by Hamish Townsend and published in 2012, gives a lively account of North Yarra Community Health's sometimes turbulent history. The book is available at Carlton, Collingwood and Fitzroy libraries. You can also view an e-copy at:
Vale Frank Del Monaco
20 June 1943 – 2 September 2018
Image: Courtesy of Del Monaco Family
The Del Monaco name is one long associated with the family clothing business begun in 1938, on the corner of Faraday and Lygon Streets, Carlton. The family name features, for instance, in the book Carlton: A History (ed. P. Yule), where the family also played a role in the establishment of the iconic La Mama Theatre, set up in the building behind the Del Monaco shop.
Frank worked for many years in the family business, and was heavily involved in local business and Italian community activities, remaining passionate about the history of Lygon Street, even after the end of the family business. He was a regular at CCHG meetings from its beginnings in 2006-07, until distance and poor health restricted him to occasional telephone contact with various members on topics that still engaged him.
He was devoted to his family, with his four brothers, and five chidren surviving him, having lost one son earlier.
La Mama up in Flames
The Aftermath of the Fire in 2018
Carlton residents woke to the shocking news that La Mama Theatre in Faraday Street was gutted by fire in the early hours of Saturday 19 May 2018.
The innovative theatre was founded by Betty Burstall in 1967, in the style of La Mama in New York. The small two-storey building, once owned by the Del Monaco family, was a printing workshop, and an underwear and shirt factory before its transformation into an intimate theatre space. Betty Burstall, the "Mama" of La Mama, died in 2013.
In the theatre tradition of "the show must go on", Saturday night's performance of Bully Virus went ahead at the alternative venue of the Kathleen Syme Library & Community Centre, on the corner of Faraday and Cardigan Streets.
Related item: Betty Burstall 1926-2013
Bridget Kinsman (née Ballot), beauty therapist of Newry Street, North Carlton, lost her fight with cancer and died on 16 May 2018. She will be remembered as a gentle and caring soul, and will be sadly missed by her family, friends and clients. Bridget opened her salon Carlton Beauty Care in 1995, in a quaint two storey building on the corner of Newry and Henry Streets. Newry Street was not a prime location for a business, compared to the main shopping area of Rathdowne Street nearby, but it worked for Bridget. Word got around and her client base grew. She never had to advertise her services because the recommendation of a satisfied client was worth more than a thousand dollars of advertising. While other businesses came and went, Bridget's was one of the longest running to continuously occupy the building.
Bridget Kinsman (13 August 1968 - 16 May 2018) was farewelled at St Peter's Eastern Hill on 24 May 2018. CCHG extends its condolences to her husband Jeff and their two sons.
The shop at 119 Newry Street was built in 1881 by W. Hearndon. It has had a variety of uses over the years, including a fancy repository, tinsmith and bootmaker and repairer.
A Host of Golden DaffodilsI wandered lonely as a cloud, that floats on high o'er vales and hills
When all at once I saw a crowd, a host of golden daffodils
William Wordsworth, 1770-1850
Daffodils in Murchison Square Carlton
The flowers that once inspired Wordsworth's poetry have finished blooming in Macarthur and Murchison Squares in Carlton, but they will be back again. The bulbs were planted by Melbourne City Council in autumn 2018, following a successful trial planting in the Fitzroy Gardens, East Melbourne, in 2016. The daffodils are expected to provide a colourful winter display for the next five years.
The squares of Carlton - Argyle, Curtain, Lincoln, Macarthur, Murchison and University - are the topic of our August 2018 newsletter.
And So To Bed
The boutique Milly Sleeping closed in February 2018, after more than 12 years in Carlton. The business at 157 Elgin Street, a small two storey shop with a narrow staircase, began in 2005. Mother and daughter team of Janette and Leah Muddle have supported local designers and stocked an eclectic range of clothing and accessories. "Milly Sleeping" was not, as might be expected, named after the two resident cats, which were sometimes seen sleeping in the front window. It was named after a painting by Ernst Kirchner.
Nearly 100 years ago, in September 1919, a very different style of business was transacted at 157 Elgin Street. Joseph Nolan, a hairdresser, appeared in Carlton Court on a charge of having used his premises for gaming purposes between 10 July and 1 September 1919. His was one of several local businesses raided by police and a search yielded the incriminating evidence of betting tickets and marked money. Nolan pleaded guilty and was fined £40, with £3 costs.
The Argus, 6 September 1919, p. 17
The Good Doctor
1942 - 2017
Dr Serge Liberman, medical general practitioner to a generation of people in Carlton, Brunswick and other inner suburbs, died on 22 December 2017. Here are thoughts and recollections from some of those for whom he was a treasured doctor, friend and writer.
Judith Biddington: There are many skilled doctors and writers in our community, but most don't have necessarily have skill in both areas. Serge Liberman did, he was a good doctor and a good and interesting writer. In addition, as a humanist and humanitarian, he had great people skills. No wonder people in Carlton followed him up to Brunswick when he moved from one suburb to the other, or flocked to his talks when he gave them. Serge had the capacity to involve you, as his patient, in what was happening to you, to explain, to answer all your questions honestly and sensibly, thereby treating you with respect. He always knew your history, even long term, over forty years for some members of our family. He was also very likeable and so many of his patients regarded him as a friend; even when they did not share his ethnicity they still enjoyed his writing and excellent scholarship. He would also have made an exceptional teacher. He will be sorely missed.
Anne Marie Lynzaat & Richard Trembath:
There are many stories I could tell about Serge Liberman who was our GP for decades. The one I shall tell comes from when he had retired, and it illustrates his compassion and empathy with his patients. About a year after he left the Lotus Medical Centre he read the death notice I had placed in the newspaper regarding my brother in law's death from pancreatic cancer. Anne Marie and I were both surprised and moved by the letter we received from Serge shortly afterwards. In it he expressed his best wishes and sympathy for our loss. He concluded with a typical dry joke that Anne Marie's unusual surname helped pick out the notice from all the others!
Shelley Marcus & Peter Tilley:
As patients of Serge Liberman in Carlton and Brunswick from the 1990's until his retirement in around 2013, my wife Shelley and I came greatly to appreciate his excellence and warmth as a GP but also his scholarly and literary interests. He was a late-20th-century version of Anton Pavlovich Chekhov, who was likewise a doctor and master of the short story. As a Russian-speaker and translator myself, I enjoyed our conversations on cultural matters during consultations. Serge received the Alan Marshall Literary Award in 1980 and 1981, and Shelley and I have an autographed copy of his 2011, 836-page magnum opus, 'The Bibliography of Australasian Judaica 1788-2008'. Serge will be much missed.
It is a rare privilege to have the wise counsel and empathy of the same doctor from the gawky edge of early adulthood until the wistful edge of retirement. I first went to the Lygon St clinic in the early 1970s with a throat complaint and soon found myself settling to see Serge whenever possible, following to new offices in Brunswick by the mid 1990s. The strictly physical complaints, increasing as I aged, he dealt with smoothly and competently, and I soon found I could also trust him to advise on matters of emotional health, with the same warm efficiency. I also discovered in his writings how deep his understanding of others could go, such as in his short story, published in The Age, of an elderly Italian widower readying to leave for Australia. Upon his retirement in 2013 I felt a door was closing on a large part of my life. Now I know it is shut for good. Addio Serge.
Serge Liberman was a popular doctor and you sometimes had to wait a while to see him, but he always gave you his full attention and care. One day I was sitting in the waiting room, suffering from what I thought was the world's worst cold, when I heard a terrible hacking cough coming from the consulting room. My symptoms were trivial by comparison with this patient, who sounded like they were at death's door. Imagine my surprise when I discovered that the "patient" was, in fact, Dr Liberman himself. He was obviously unwell, but he was still seeing a few patients before going home to rest. He wrote a certificate for my time off work and, with his characteristic humour, he pushed a blank form towards me and asked if I could write a certificate for him. I gave him the rest of the week off.
An obituary, with an overview of his life and work, appears in the Sydney Morning Herald.
As well as his medical work, Serge Liberman was a chronicler of Jewish, and also of other migrant lives, in Carlton and other parts of Melbourne, which came alive in his writings. Much of his writing output can be found at his website.
In December 2014 Serge Liberman gave a talk to the Carlton Community History Group entitled "Writing Jewish Carlton". A copy of the talk can be found on the Academia website.
Dracula's Last Bite
The Canals Have Gone Fishing
Two well known Carlton businesses - Dracula's Theatre Restaurant and Canals Seafood - shut up shop in 2017. Dracula's began in Drewery Lane, Melbourne, in 1980 and moved to larger premises at 96-100 Victoria Street, Carlton, ten years later in 1990. The converted brick factory site, on the corner of Cardigan Street, was originally designed by architect P. Hudson in 1912 and built by F. Frenchman for Ross, Robbins Co., brassfounders. Dracula's final performance was on Saturday 23 December 2017.
Canals Seafood, at 703 Nicholson Street, North Carlton, celebrated its 100th anniversary in 2017. The business began as a fish and chip shop, operated by Spanish migrants Joseph and Maria Canals, in Collingwood in 1917. They moved to North Carlton in the early 1930s and took over an existing fishmonger's shop, which had been in Nicholson Street as early as 1905. Canals is a family business in the true sense, with successive generations learning the trade from their elders and making their own contribution to developing the business. Over the decades, migrants from Europe, like the Canals family, have done much to influence the Australian taste for fish and seafood. In 2017, the demand for quality seafood was greater than ever and the Canals brothers, John and Peter, chose to end on a high note and give themselves a well-earned break in retirement. The shop building was auctioned in October 2017 and a new seafood business, The Fishmonger's Son, opened in May 2018.
Notes and References:
Building occupancy information has been sourced from Sands and McDougall directories.
Building design information has been sourced from the Australian Architectural Index and Building Application Index.
The Age, 28 September 2017
Elm Trees in Curtain Square North Carlton
Looking South Towards Newry Street
Tree Removal in Curtain Square North Carlton
From Quarry to Quercus
Curtain Square North Carlton
Curtain Square in North Carlton has had a major landscape change, with the removal of twelve elm trees from its north/south avenue. Six of the mature elm trees, estimated at 100 years old, were assessed as having structural defects and they posed a serious risk to public safety. The remaining elm trees, from more recent plantings, were not growing well in their current position and their removal allowed for a new avenue of 16 trees to be planted. The Scarlet Oak, Quercus coccinea, was selected as the replacement species. Tree removal took place in September 2017 and care was taken to minimise disruption to the resident wildlife population.
Of course, it will take some time for the new avenue of trees to become established, but Curtain Square has gone through many changes in its history. Curtain Square occupies 1.46 hectares of the area bounded by Rathdowne, Canning, Curtain and Newry Streets and the land was first reserved for recreational purposes in May 1876. However, it had an earlier history as a quarry worked by convicts from the Collingwood Stockade from 1853 to 1866. The convicts spent their days doing back breaking work in the quarry, hewing blocks of bluestone with hand tools, then they were marched back to the stockade (now the site of North Carlton Primary School in Lee Street) to be locked up overnight.
The contrast between the work of the convicts and the amenity of Curtain Square as a public recreational space could not be greater. A report in The Argus of April 1877 spoke in glowing terms of the area being "hardly recognisable as the place it was 12 months ago". The old quarry holes were filled in and the area was planted with a variety of trees and shrubs in pleasing arrangements. It was noted "the great hollows which formerly existed have been filled up with street sweepings, and are now being covered with a thick layer of mould." The legacy of this infill material was noted a hundred and fifteen years later in the Curtain Square Masterplan of 1992. Cracks in the walls of buildings, constructed in the 1930s and 1940s, were attributed to subsidence on the former quarry site, as was the tilt of the elm trees in the vicinity. The buildings, a "men's shelter" and a toilet block, were demolished in the 1990s.
The reserve, also known as Curtain's Square, was named in honour of John Curtain, who was instrumental in having the land reserved for ornamental and recreational purposes. He was a Melbourne City Councillor and Member of Parliament, the publican of several hotels in Carlton and a well known real estate developer, who at one stage owned over fifty properties in Carlton. Curtain Street, on the northern boundary of the square, is also named after him.
Curtain Square tree replacements, City of Yarra, 2017
Crown Title, Vol. 887, Folio 273, 5 May 1876
The Argus, 6 April 1877, p. 5. This article includes a detailed list of trees planted in the reserve.
Curtain Square Masterplan, Urban Design Team, City of Melbourne, April 1992, p. 6
It is with great sadness that CCHG notes the death at 93 years old of "Bea". Her recollections of her Carlton childhood were recorded in 2010 and provide a vivid insight into the kind of lives lived by poorer residents in what was then a vibrant working class suburb, as well as describing the effects of the outbreak of World War 2 on a young woman just finding her feet in the world of employment.
Bea married soon after the war and over the decades raised a family of four and gradually acquired the professional qualifications and experience she had missed out on when she left school at 14. Additionally, at the age of 64, she undertook an Arts degree majoring in Art History and Italian. She described those years at university as the highlight of her life. It was characteristic of her energy that, when she was interviewed at the age of 86, she was still employing an Italian tutor to work with her and a small group of friends in maintaining their language skills.
Bea spent the last couple of years of her life in an aged care home, something her daughters suggested to her with some trepidation as a temporary respite but which, characteristically, she enjoyed so much that she immediately elected to make it permanent.
Vale Bea, a full life indeed.
Who would have thought that waiting for her friend to change her stocking could have made such a difference? Read Bea's story and find out how this seemingly trivial event had a big impact on her young life.
A Fruitful Business
Good news for Rathdowne Street shoppers - the former St Clements greengrocer, which closed in February 2017, has re-opened under new management in May 2017. Senserrick, originally at 687 Nicholson Street North Carlton, has expanded its business into Rathdowne Street. Senserrick and St Clements are the latest in a long line of greengrocers that have occupied the shop at 384 Rathdowne Street since the 1930s, with the exception of a few years from the late 1940s when it was a wholesale hardware business. Longer term residents will remember the Tucci family, who operated the greengrocer's business from the mid 1950s through to the 1990s. The purchase of fruit and vegetables was often accompanied by an impromptu Italian lesson, courtesy of Francesca and Paolo. They retained ownership of the building after their retirement and the business has been continued by a succession of greengrocers. Paolo died in April 1993 and Francesca in June 2016, at the age of 90 years. Both were buried in Melbourne General Cemetery, Carlton.
The two storey shop building was sold in late 2016 and 384 Rathdowne Street is once again selling fruit and vegetables.
Image: Courtesy of Tucci Family
The Tucci Family in the 1960s
The Samovar Travels On
The Travelling Samovar closed in late 2016 and the former tea house entered the next phase of its history as the café Extension of Time, opened in February 2017. The new café retains a link with the Travelling Samovar and has a small selection of Samovar teas available.
The two-storey building at 412 Rathdowne Street, North Carlton, which dates back to the 1890s, was a tobacconist shop for sixty years. None of the subsequent business occupants - pastrycook, confectioner, milk bar, picture framer, noodle shop, café or tea house - can rival the tobacconist in terms of longevity. Read more about the tobacconist shop that became a tea house.
An upstairs fireplace and surrounding brickwork is all that remains of the original Carlton Inn Hotel
Another One Bites the Dust
One of Carlton's earliest extant hotel buildings, on the corner of Leicester and Pelham Streets, was demolished illegally over the weekend of 16 and 17 October 2016. The Corkman Irish Pub, which was subject to a heritage overlay, was reduced to rubble, despite a stop-work order being issued by the Melbourne City Council. The hotel was originally built as the Carlton Inn and first licensed to George Edmonds (Edmunds) in 1856. Over the next one hundred and sixty years, the hotel served many glasses of beer and played host to generations of university student pub crawls.
At the time the Carlton Inn was built, the area north of Victoria Street, including Carlton and parts of North Melbourne, was not subject to the provisions of the Melbourne Building Act (1849). Buildings could be constructed and demolished without permits and this contributed to the somewhat haphazard development of Carlton in its early days. Nowadays, there is a rigorous system of planning, building and demolition permits in place, but this was not enough to save the Corkman Irish Pub, which will be sadly missed.
Notes and References:
An Act for Regulating Buildings and Party Walls and for Preventing Mischiefs by Fire in the City of Melbourne, 12 October 1849 (Melbourne Building Act, 1849)
The Age, 7 May 1856, p. 2
Melbourne Planning Scheme. City North Heritage Review, 2013 (Revised June 2015)
At CCHG's September 2016 meeting, Dr Renate Howe gave an interesting presentation on the battle for Melbourne's inner suburbs in the 1960s and 1970s, based on the book Trendyville, which she co-authored. Dr Howe has kindly allowed CCHG to post a copy of her presentation notes on its website. If you missed the meeting, or if you would like revisit Trendyville, you can view the notes here.
The book Trendyville is available from Monash University Publishing.
Former Bank Building
Corner of Elgin and Rathdowne Streets Carlton
Notes and References:
1 Elgin Scrap Metals Pty Ltd owned the corner site from 1980 to 1984, when ownership was transferred to Mordcha Pty Ltd.
2 Bank branch locations sourced from advertisements in Sands and McDougall.
3 The Argus, 24 March 1884, p. 15
4 Australian Architectural Index, record no. 78821
5 The National Bank of Australasia was established in 1858, two years after the Colonial Bank of Australasia.
6 Geoffrey Blainey and Geoffrey Hutton. Gold and paper 1858-1982 : A history of the National Bank of Australasia, Macmillan, 1983. p. 184
7 ibid, p. 322
The Last Bank in Elgin Street
Bank branch closures are all too common in the era of internet banking, but for the National Australia Bank in Carlton, it was a case of "one branch closes and another opens." The Carlton branch at 129 Elgin Street closed its doors on Friday 12 August 2016 and re-opened at 288 Lygon Street on Wednesday 17 August. The branch had occupied the single-storey building on the south west Rathdowne Street corner site, next to Elgin Scrap Metals, since 1984. But the bank's history in Carlton goes back another hundred years. 1
The Colonial Bank of Australasia was established in 1856 and by 1884 it had fifty branches in town and country Victoria. In March 1884, a small advertisement appeared in The Argus inviting tenders for the erection of a new Colonial Bank of Australasia at Carlton. The following month, a notice of intent was lodged with Melbourne City Council to construct a bank building on the north west corner of Rathdowne and Elgin Streets (later numbered 126 Elgin Street). The bank was designed by architects Smith & Johnson and built by Alex Kemp of Rathdowne Street, North Carlton. There were branches of the Bank of Victoria, Commercial Bank of Australia, London Chartered Bank, and Savings Bank of Victoria already established in Carlton, but the economy was booming in the 1880s and increased competition was considered good for business. A few years later, the Colonial Bank of Australasia survived the depression of the 1890s, while many other banks and financial institutions went to the wall. 2,3,4
The final phase of the Colonial Bank of Australasia's life came in the immediate post-World War 1 period. The Colonial Bank of Australasia merged with the larger National Bank of Australasia, in what was regarded as a positive business move at the time. On 25 November 1918, the Colonial Bank of Australasia went into liquidation and its staff, accounts and premises were transferred to the National Bank of Australasia. The stationery and signage at the Carlton branch was changed and the bank continued to operate at the Rathdowne Street corner site until the 1980s. 5,6
The 1980s saw major changes, with government deregulation of the banking and finance sector. The National Bank of Australasia merged with the Commercial Banking Company in 1982 to become the National Australia Bank. The Carlton branch at 126 Elgin Street moved across the street to the newly-constructed building at 129 Elgin Street in 1984, and remained there until its closure in 2016. While the National Australia Bank still has a branch in the Lygon Street tourist precinct, Elgin Street has, regrettably, lost its last bank. 7
Tree Removal in Canning Street North Carlton
A Silent Protest
Notes and References:
1 Arboricultural Assessment. Location: Canning Street and Drummond Street Carlton North. Ref.: 2145.AA.3, 16 February 2016
2 Gippsland Times, 8 February 1937, p. 3
3 The Age, 24 February 1937, p. 12
Carlton is blessed with many street trees, the most notable plantings being in Canning, Drummond and Rathdowne Streets. The poplar trees in Canning Street, North Carlton, were planted in the median strip over fifty years ago and are now reaching the end of their lifespan. In November 2015, two large trees came down near the North Carlton Primary School and crashed onto parked cars. Fortunately there were no injuries, but there was significant property damage and the risk of future tree incidents. As a result, City of Yarra commissioned a study to assess the condition of all poplar trees in Canning and Drummond Streets. The study recommended removal of selected trees in both streets and works commenced in June 2016. The median strip trees were replaced with new plantings in spring 2016, thus continuing nature's cycle of growth, decline and renewal.1
Back in 1937, Carlton's attitude towards street trees was very different. The Melbourne City Council proposed a plantation in the centre of Rathdowne Street, as part of a tree planting scheme to commemorate the coronation of King George VI. The Council's ambitious scheme to plant a total of 5,000 trees within the municipality, at a cost of £20,000 over several years, met with strong resistance from the ratepayers of Victoria Ward. A door-to-door survey of shops and businesses in Rathdowne Street revealed 87 against and only 3 in favour of the proposed plantation. Anti-tree sentiment was running high, with some residents stating they would cut down any trees planted. The main reasons for objection were that a tree plantation would detract from the commercial appearance and character of the street, and would be a hindrance to vehicular traffic, which had increased since motor buses replaced the old cable trams in 1936. Business interests and traffic ruled in 1937 and the plantation proposal was abandoned.2,3
Rathdowne Street had to wait another four decades for its plantation, implemented in almost opposite circumstances. The controversial eastern freeway opened in 1977, amidst protests from Council, local businesses and residents alike. Rathdowne Street had become a feeder road for the freeway, via Princes Street, and Council proposed a median strip to slow down traffic and improve local amenity. This proposal was successful and, decades later, the median strip of mature trees contributes to Rathdowne Street's unique character and continues to be an asset, rather than a hindrance, to local businesses and residents.
Tony Does Carlton
The Carlton episode of Tony Robinson's Time Walks was broadcast on ABC 1 on Friday 20 May 2016. Naturally he covers the Trades Hall and the Eight Hour Memorial. But if his points of focus are predictable, his treatment of them is not necessarily so.
The Exhibition Building? Check! But instead of dwelling on the architectural wonders, he describes the unpleasant state of the grounds in the early days and recounts a nineteenth century academic scrap over the palaeontology collection housed in the basement. Italians? Of course, but after we see a venerable espresso machine and hear Nino Borsari's son tell his father's story, a visit to Dorrit Street deftly combines the stories of Carlton's early Italian migrants, who arrived about 1890, the Viggianese street musicians, and that of Jean Lee, the last woman to be hanged in Australia. Her story is the only reference to the seamier side of Carlton's history, something of an imbalance perhaps. The program moves on to La Mama and an extended segment explores the flavour and political influence of one production from this long-running and hugely influential Carlton institution.
Inevitably in such a short program there are omissions. There is no coverage of the Jewish presence in Carlton. We see the grand terraces of Drummond Street, but learn nothing of their decline into boarding houses in the early twentieth century or of the gradual gentrification of Carlton as a whole from the 1970s.
The Trades Hall : Part of Our History
Murder at Mallow House
Betty Burstall (Founder of La Mama)
Tony de Bolfo (left) and CCHG President Jeff Atkinson
Carlton Football Club
The 2016 footy season kicked off with a lively presentation by Tony De Bolfo at the Kathleen Syme Library and Community Centre on Saturday 2 April. Tony de Bolfo, official historian of the Carlton Football Club, traced the Club's origins back to a meeting at the University Hotel, corner of Lygon and Grattan Streets, in 1864. This was the start of a long association with Carlton pubs, including the use of the Clyde Hotel, corner of Cardigan and Elgin Streets, as change rooms before the Club was granted a permanent home at Princes Park in 1896.
Tony's presentation featured historic photos of the Club and its players, and the houses in Carlton and Parkville where some of them lived.
For more information, visit the Blueseum website at www.blueseum.org
Image source: CCHG
This signage recalls an earlier era, when mixed bathing was a novelty.
Notes and References:
1 Carlton : a history, Melbourne University Press, 2004, p. 316
2 The Age, 21 February 1930, p. 12
3 The Age, 4 February 1930, p. 8
4 Barrier Miner, 7 February 1930, p. 1
5 Properties condemned under section 56 of the Housing Act 1958 (VPRS 1824)
100 Years of Bathing
The Carlton Baths celebrated its 100th birthday with a pool party on Saturday 13 February 2016.
The baths were offically opened on 11 February 1916, with the original entrance via Victoria Place, a laneway running off Princes Street. In the early days, the pool water was not filtered or chlorinated, and was changed once a week. The introduction of mixed bathing at Carlton and North Melbourne Baths, approved by Melbourne City Council in October 1929, led to major improvements. Five houses in Rathdowne Street (nos. 240-248) were demolished to build a new entrance and changing facitities for both sexes. A filtration plant was installed, an important public health consideration when many houses in Carlton did not have bathrooms and local residents used the baths for personal bathing.1
The Carlton Baths were re-opened by Councillor H.G. Smith, chairman of the Baths Committee, on 20 February 1930, but had been in operation for several weeks beforehand. The Age of 4 February 1930 reported a spate of thefts at the Carlton Baths and one unfortunate man had his trousers stolen. In the same month, a major incident occurred during a heat wave when a crowd of 200 people - men, women and children - stormed the turnstiles and climbed over the 7 foot high iron gates to gain access to the cooling waters of the pool. The police were called in to restore order, and an estimated 1000 people entered the pool over the next few hours, with barely enough room for swimming.2,3,4
More recent improvements have seen the Carlton Baths transformed from a basic swimming pool into a sporting and recreational complex. In the early 1970s, five more houses (nos. 222-230 Rathdowne Street) were demolished to make way for expansion on the south side, and the site now occupies half the Rathdowne Street frontage between Neill and Princes Streets.5
Giacomo and Gina Basso in their shop in 2012
Gina Basso : A Film Star at 83?
The Carlton Community History Group has previously demonstrated its admiration for the persistence and hard work of Giacomo and Gina Basso and we registered our condolences on the death of Giacomo in September last year. Speaking to Gina just recently it is clear that, despite missing her husband badly, her determination and strength of character remain undiminished.
Gina continues to work in the tailoring business she and Giacomo set up so many years ago but now she works on alterations mainly by herself, although her grand daughter spends a couple of hours a week working with her. She explains, "It's a bit hard", but she has to pay the bills. Work also helps her maintain her English. Her son calls in about three times a week to ensure she is alright and has successfully negotiated the 18 steps she walks up and down every day to reach the rooms on the second floor of the dwelling. She still enjoys cooking for him and other members of the family, like her grand daughter who, when she was only 14, painted a splendid portrait of Giacomo. However, as Gina says "Age makes things difficult. It's as if there is no future. Life is not for you." Nevertheless she keeps going, although living by herself means it is difficult having no one to mull over things which happen every day or sort out problems.
Gina is about to have another birthday and she has just been approached by a film company wanting to make a film about her house and the business. As she continues to maintain her charm and good looks, and knowing the complexity of her history, and how versatile she has proved herself, it seems very likely she could be a film star at 83.
CCHG wishes Gina well, is proud to know her and looks forward to the film adding to our record of local history.
Des Norman in his studio in 2012
Vale Des Norman
It is with deep regret that the Carlton Community History Group notes the death of Des Norman, on 13 September 2015, and sends condolences to his thoughtful wife Stella, and other family members, including their daughter Ruth, who brought Des's work to our attention. He will be sadly missed.
CCHG got to know Des in the process of working on his book of paintings, which we published as Through the Eyes of a Child : A Street in Carlton, 1939-45. He was extremely generous and the more contact we had, the more we valued his insights.
His was an unusual approach to our local history and offered a unique glimpse at what it was like to live through the war years in Dorrit Street, Carlton and attend the Faraday Street school, now the Kathleen Syme Centre. That selection of his paintings throws light on his experiences as a boy, living in a small house, whose bedroom was the narrow front verandah, with only a canvas blind between him and the street. A street where he and his friends went to school and played together, or observed the adults of many cultures he knew or saw, going about their lives, in war-time Carlton. It is an extraordinary and extremely valuable record.
This book is only a part of Des Norman's enormous contribution to art, from early works on Daisy Bates, a collection portraying the battlefields of Gallipoli and a resurrection series, to other major exhibitions, restoration work, commissions and illustrations. As a fellow staff member of the Melbourne Church of England Grammar School said, his work 'encapsulates honesty and sensitivity' in presenting images which 'can be sensually poignant and at the same time, disturbingly evocative'.
Des Norman was farewelled by family and friends on Wednesday 23 September 2015 and he now lies resting in Kangaroo Ground Cemetery. The date was specially chosen by Stella, as it would have been their 65th wedding anniversary.
The Mystery Man of Dorrit Street
From Surrey Hills to Carlton
In August 2015 CCHG received an email asking if we were interested in a centenary souvenir booklet of the Queensberry Street Primary School. The answer was, of course, a resounding "Yes" and we have now taken delivery of the booklet, which charts the history of the school from its opening in 1881 and closure in 1932, through to its later function as the Education Department Physical Education Branch. The former school building at 224 Queensberry Street Carlton is now home to the University of Melbourne Queensberry Children's Centre. The school (S.S. no. 2365) rates only a passing mention in Peter Yule's book Carlton : a history, so the booklet will be a valuable addition to our small resource collection.
CCHG thanks the Surrey Hills Neighbourhood Centre Heritage Collection for this generous donation and also for thinking of us - for that's what community is all about.
Photo reproduced with kind permission from the Bassos and CoAsIt
Gina Basso (nee Costa) dancing with her husband Giacomo, soon after her arrival in Melbourne in 1953
Giacomo and Gina in their shop in 2012
The Bassos of North Carlton : A Love Story and a Full Life
In 2013 Giacomo and Gina Basso celebrated living and working in Rathdowne Street for over 60 years. That by itself is some feat, but when people realise something of their Italian backgrounds and the various trials and tribulations this steadfast, courageous couple have weathered, the celebrations seem low key for a 93 and 81 year old.
Both of them came from large extended Italian farming families, in an area depressed by urban development. Both experienced the 2nd World War on the losing side and both started working very young - Gina part-time from the age of 7, to fill in the half days she was not at school while her mother worked more hours on the family farm, and Giacomo at 13, as he was the eldest of four who had to help support his family after his father had died when Giacomo was 9, and his mother died 7 years later. While Giacomo's training was limited, Gina thoroughly learned dressmaking and embroidery until at 15 she began training as a men's tailor in the place where Giacomo was working. They fell in love and have been together ever since, apart from the separation when Giacomo went to Turin in late 1949 to make robes for the Christian Brothers and then migrated to Australia, not his first choice. He sold his only asset, some land, to pay his fare and with the support of a Myrtleford tobacco grower and his Italian friend Sante Forte, he landed in Australia in early 1951.
Almost immediately finding a job, earning money and learning a new language were problems for the 32 year old, who wanted to save enough to bring Gina to Australia, despite the fact that Gina's mother was unhappy with her leaving. They were married by proxy, with one of Giacomo's brothers, Giovanni, standing in for the bridegroom on 6 July 1953, while on the same day in Australia, Giacomo and another of his brothers, Antonio, paid the deposit they had saved on what was then a dilapidated building in Rathdowne Street, in which they still live.
As a couple they faced living and working as tailors in the same place, home renovations with very limited funds, rearranged mortgages, the problems of learning a new language for Gina and learning to drive for Giacomo, lack of privacy, council regulations, noise from traffic and machinery next door, as well as drunken customers from the Kent Hotel. These were balanced against having a son, Robert, family connections, good and generous friends and neighbours, both Italian and Australian.
Giacomo summed up their lives:
"It has been hard at times, particularly when sickness strikes, but very rewarding. We have enjoyed our life and are proud of what we have done together and how we have weathered adversity at times. We have real joy in each other, our son, his wife and children, our lovely grandchildren, our in-laws have been an added bonus. We have been very fortunate to have our son marry into a supportive family."
Sadly, Giacomo died on 19 September 2014. He was a well respected member of the local community, with a friendly word for all, combined with a slighly cheeky twinkle of the eye.
Carlton Community History Group acknowledges the generosity and openness of this remarkable family.
Contact CCHG for access to interview transcripts and other material on the Bassos.
12-18 Shakespeare Street, North Carlton
Notes and References:
1 Melbourne Leader, 14 August, 2014
2 Property ownership information sourced from land title records
3 Building application file, BA 10595 (VPRS 11201)
4 The Argus, 21 July 1930, p. 7
5 Victorian Heritage Database
6 Properties condemned under section 56 of the Housing Act 1958 files (VPRS 1824)
7 The two-storey house at 8 Shakespeare Street was condemned by the Housing Commission in 1970, but it was declared fit for human habitation after the required repairs were completed.
8 Melbourne Times, 17 November 1976, p. 1
The Scouts are Back
After an absence of 25 years, the scouts and cubs are back in newly renovated premises in Shakespeare Street North Carlton. The scout hall, which dominates the north side of Shakespeare Street, was home to the Handspinners & Weavers Guild from 2000 to 2011, when they moved to shopfront premises in Nicholson Street.1
Shakespeare Street dates back to 1870, when John Green and John Ryan purchased allotments 1, 2, 9 and 10 in the area bounded by Lygon, Fenwick and Drummond streets. Within six months, the land was onsold to David Henry, who was responsible for the subdivision that made up the structure of Shakespeare Street. During the 1870s and 1880s houses were built on both sides of the street, but the 60 feet wide block on the north side remained largely undeveloped. The site served as a workshop for Enoch Jones, model maker, and remained in the Jones Family from 1885 to 1927.2
A building application for the scout hall, designed by architect Harry James and to be built by J. Perryman, was lodged on 18 May 1928. The foundation stone was laid by the Lord Mayor Councillor Luxton in July 1930 and, on completion in October 1930, the scout hall was the last building to fill the street. The hall was purpose-built for public performances, with a raised platform, off-stage dressing rooms and cloakrooms. It served a dual purpose in providing a home base for the First Carlton Troop and also a source of income from hiring out the premises for public and private functions. The hall is described as "a well-preserved but late example of Neo-baroque styling, with steel-framed windows and segmental arches to openings" in the Victorian Heritage Database. It is considered "socially and historically significant for its public role in North Carlton." 3,4,5
Shakespeare Street came under threat in the 1950s and 1960s, when the Housing Commission of Victoria declared five houses on the south side, nos. 7 to 15 inclusive, as unfit for human habitation. One property owner appealed to the Housing Commission to buy them out, but to no avail. Shakespeare Street was not in a proclaimed slum reclamation area and the Housing Commission had no interest, beyond ordering the demolition of what they considered to be an unfit dwelling on a substandard block of land. The houses were demolished in January 1970, leaving an open space ripe for redevelopment. The vacant block became an illegal rubbish dump, while the new owner argued with the Melbourne City Council over the valuation of the land. Then local residents took action, at their own expense, by cleaning up the site and creating a mini park for the benefit and enjoyment of the whole community. In 1978, the Melbourne City Council entered into an agreement to purchase the land, with local residents contributing part of the cost. The mini park, used by the scouts and residents alike, remains a tribute to the power of community action.6,7,8
More information on Shakespeare Street
The Shaw Davey Slum (Former Pugg Mahones)
Corner of Drummond and Elgin Streets, Carlton
Notes and References:
1 The survey recommendations were submitted to the Hon. H.R. Petty M.L.A., Minister of Housing, on 24 June 1960 and appeared in the Report on slum reclamation and urban redevelopment of Melbourne inner suburban areas, dated 21 July 1960.
2 Area no. 4 (approximately 74.2 acres in Carlton) was bounded by Princes, Nicholson and Lygon Streets and the rear of properties facing Elgin Street.
3 Area no. 4A (approximately 49.0 acres in North Carlton) was bounded by Lygon, Fenwick, Canning, Princes, Rathdowne and Lee Streets, excluding Curtain Square, the Kindergarten and Primary School.
4 The Australian Dictionary of Biography cites 1863 for John Curtain's Hotel, but this date is not supported by the evidence of Melbourne City Council Rate Books (VPRS 5708), Liquor Licensing Records (VPRS 7601) or a statutory declaration signed by John Curtain in 1882 (VPRS 460/P1/1154/50881).
5 Hotel names information sourced from Sands & McDougall and the R.K. Collection of Hotel Records.
Slumming it in Carlton
The Shaw Davey Slum, a refurbished bar opened for trading in May 2014, recalls a controversial survey from 1960 that identified large areas of Carlton and North Carlton for slum reclamation. Based on a comparison of two independent surveys conducted by J.H. Davey (Slum Research Officer) and Grahame Shaw (Senior Architect, Design & Research) of the Victorian Housing Commission, it was dubbed the "windscreen survey", amidst claims that the officers had simply driven through the inner suburbs and noted areas for reclamation. Shaw and Davey concluded:
There is danger that spasmodic rebuilding may eventually hinder complete redevelopment by enforcing adherence to the present road and right-of-way pattern - resulting in crowded housing in perpetuity. Only a vigorous programme of reclamation in known defined areas will deter owners from rebuilding on small sites.1
While many areas of the inner suburbs were lost to slum reclamation, community action and changing attitudes to social housing have meant that the Shaw Davey survey recommendations were never fully realised. In an almost complete turnaround, architects and builders are now coming up with creative solutions for rebuilding on small sites, which are in great demand and can command high prices.
Despite the choice of name, the Shaw Davey Slum is not actually within the reclamation area as defined by the survey, which stopped at the rear of properties on the north side of Elgin Street. The Shaw Davey Slum, on the southwest corner of Drummond and Elgin Streets, continues a long tradition of hotels dating back to the 1860s. Curtain's Hotel, also known as the Elgin Hotel, was built in 1865/66 and first licensed to Irishman John Curtain in February 1866. He went on to pursue a career in business and politics, but he suffered heavy financial losses, resulting in the sale of the hotel and other property holdings. The hotel was next licensed to Henry Bew in 1871 and John Fleming in 1873, when it became known as Fleming's Hotel. The name later reverted to Curtain's Hotel until the 1920s, when it became Stewart's Hotel for the remainder of the 20th century. In the 21st century, John Curtain's Hotel returned to its Irish roots as Pugg Mahones.2,3,4,5
More information on John Curtain
Memorial stone on grave of James Colgan (1846-1899)
Melbourne General Cemetery
A New Street in Carlton
Carlton has a new street, on the former Housing Commission redevelopment site. Colgan Street runs for one block between Rathdowne and Drummond Streets, providing access to the new Australian Unity retirement living and aged care facility at 497 Rathdowne Street. Unlike nearby Reeves Street, which originally dated back to the 1860s, there was no pre-existing street at this location. However, the street name has historical links with both Carlton and Australian Unity.
James Colgan was born in Melbourne in 1846, the son of John Colgan and Margaret Leary. A law clerk, he was one of the founding members of the Australian Natives' Association (A.N.A.), a friendly society formed in 1871. He was the first Treasurer of the Board of Directors in 1877 and was appointed Secretary in 1878. He retired in 1881 and became a Trustee.
James Colgan was a resident of Carlton and lived at 345 Canning Street towards the end of his life. He died on 13 August 1899, one month short of his 53rd birthday. He was survived by his widow Sarah Agnes, who he married in 1872, and two adult children. Members of A.N.A. subscribed to a fund for the erection of a memorial stone above his grave in the Melbourne General Cemetery. The memorial stone was unveiled on 30 August 1901. Sarah Colgan died in 1924 and was buried with her husband.
A.N.A. merged with Manchester Unity and became Australian Unity in 1993.
Birth, death and marriage records
Melbourne General Cemetery burial records
Probate file no. 72/302, 1899 (VPRS 28)
A Centenary History of the Australian Natives' Association, Horticultural Press, 1971
Pat and The Poppyshop
Pat Knox, Carlton identity and owner of the Poppyshop, retired in 2014 after 47 years of business in Lygon Street. During that time, Pat has seen many changes in manufacturing and retailing, within the broader context of major social and political change in Carlton from the 1960s through to the present day. A savvy businesswoman, Pat has remained true to her ideal of selling good quality toys and gifts at a reasonable price.
Pat shared her memories of the Poppyshop with CCHG at a meeting in July 2010:
One of the things that people love about the Poppyshop, and I love it too, is that it's a happy place. People come in and they're happy, they're nice, they talk to each other. I have a lot of people who come in nearly every day, lonely people and they just come in and say "Hi" and we have a chat.
Pat Knox and the Poppyshop have made so many people happy over the years. CCHG wishes her every happiness in her retirement.
Former Tel Aviv Dairy
183 Macpherson Street North Carlton
The Tel Aviv Dairy of North Carlton
The sale in February 2014 of the property at 183 Macpherson Street has broken one of the last links with the Jewish era in North Carlton. In 1926 the recently-emigrated Pahoff family took over the house and dairy at this address, running it until the 1960s when such businesses were no longer viable, and the house has remained in the family ever since. Like Glickman's bakery, Polonsky's butcher shop and Gotlib's grocery, Pahoff's Tel Aviv dairy features regularly in Jewish memoirs. The sour cream, it appears, was especially good. But the family is perhaps even better remembered for its remarkable work in sponsoring and organising the emigration of no fewer than forty families from their native Ukraine.
Photo: Courtesy of Ruth Bailey's family
Ruth Bailey 1941-2013
Vale Ruth Bailey
It was with great sadness that CCHG heard of the death of Ruth Bailey in late December 2013.
In 2010 CCHG was extremely fortunate in having the opportunity of interviewing Ruth, who was, like her mother and maternal grandmother, a Carlton girl born and bred.
Born in 1941, Ruth spent her childhood in what is now the first house north of the Carlton Gardens on the eastern side of Rathdowne Street and attended the nearby school, now Carlton Gardens Primary. She was also a regular visitor to a house in Palmerston Street opposite what is now Neill Street school. Her mother Keziah Blackburn had grown up in that house and her grandmother Alice Booth lived there during her long widowhood. When in the 1960s Alice became too frail to live alone, Ruth was newly married with a young baby and delighted to move into the house and area she knew so well. She remained there until her death.
Ruth was a delightful person to interview, with tremendous recall of detail, endless anecdotes and the rare ability to structure what she had to say so that it was effortless for her listener to follow her story. As a tribute to Ruth, CCHG has published a new booklet titled "Carlton Girls Born and Bred".
Visit our publications page for more information.
Photos: Courtesy of John E. Thompson
Council Dump near North Carlton Railway Station
Photographed in the 1960s
Vale John Duncan
Sadly, John Duncan, a CCHG supporter and contributor, passed away in 2013. He first contacted us several years ago, having enjoyed some of our material, and provided a great deal of colourful detail about his childhood in Princes Hill in the 1950s. It was, he said, a wonderful place to grow up.
On the other side of the railway line a little west of the station (now the North Carlton Neighbourhood House) was a massive junk yard, complete with dog and grumpy old watchman. We used to find all sorts of things including horse shoe nails, boxes & boxes of them. Despite many boots in the backside it was a favourite playground, as was the cemetery. The only school excursion I ever went on was a "trip to the country" by train to Diamond Creek for the day, with the nuns in all the heavy black regalia of the day and it was so hot.
It was on days like this that the kids enjoyed their local "pools", a huge tank in the local dye works and another at what was then Pullars Dry Cleaners in Rathdowne Street. John recalled the names of many local shopkeepers, especially those near the corner of Lygon and Paterson Streets where he went to school. He remembered crowding into a neighbour's house to watch the first television set in the street, and the dairy across the road at 69 Wilson Street. Carlton had a bad reputation at the time.
At a very tender age I knew of several sly groggers who the locals could go to to buy beer after hours and even Sundays, then there were at least 3-4 SP Bookmakers within walking distance of home. Dad ran one with his mate behind the Rising Sun Hotel.
One of the best of John's stories has been recorded on the Recollections page of this website under the heading Mr Briggs' Business.
CCHG is deeply grateful to John and those like him who record their memories. Our sincere condolences to his family.
Carlton's Forgotten Prison
The Carlton Community History Group congratulates member Jeff Atkinson for winning a commendation in a recent essay competition run by the Prahran Mechanics Institute.
The Prahran Mechanics' Institute is a non-profit community organisation that operates a lending library specialising in the history of Victoria. One of its objectives is to encourage and facilitate historical research, and its Short History Prize was run as a way of achieving this. Entrants were invited to submit works relating to "a history of a place or an aspect of a place in Victoria".
The winner, announced in October 2013, was John Merry of the Sandringham & District Historical Society for an entry entitled A Boyhood by the Bay : Personal Reminiscences of My Life in Sandringham in the 1940s. Two other essays were commended including Jeff's, which had been submitted on behalf of the Carlton Community History Group. His essay, entitled The Stockade : Carlton's Forgotten Prison told the story of a low security prison that operated from 1853 to 1866 in what was then bushland just north of the town of Melbourne, but which is now the built-up suburb of North Carlton.
An extended version of Jeff Atkinson's essay was published as a book in 2018. For more information, visit the Publications page.
A Tramway Terminus in Station Street
Some time ago, CCHG put out a call for help in shedding light on the origin of the name "Station Street" in Carlton. The call has been answered by Carlton resident Mike Krockenberger, who has discovered a possible connection between Station Street and the Yan Yean tramway.
A plan of allotments at Carlton, North Melbourne, Parish of Jika Jika, dated 3 August 1859, shows the area bounded by Station, Elgin, Nicholson and Neill Streets marked as "Land set apart for Yan Yean Tramway Terminus." In the 1850s Matthew Bullock Jackson proposed that a wooden tramway, built to aid pipe-laying for Melbourne's water supply from Yan Yean, could be converted into a railway line for carrying building materials and passengers. This major transport project never went ahead and the land was released for sale in 1863.
The digitised map can be viewed online at the State Library of Victoria's website.
Plan of allotments at Carlton, North Melbourne, Parish of Jika Jika, 1859 (State Library of Victoria)
Yan Yean : A history of Melbourne's early water supply, Tony Dingle and Helen Doyle, PROV, 2003
Squizzy Taylor in Carlton
Have you been watching Underbelly Squizzy, screened on Channel 9 in 2013? The TV series has revived interest in Melbourne's notorious gangster Joseph Leslie Theodore "Squizzy" Taylor and raised speculation about the historical content of the events portrayed. Carlton played a key role in Squizzy's demise, as the place where he spent his final hour on 27 October 1927. More information
Photo: Courtesy Burstall Family
4 February 1926 - 14 June 2013
Betty Burstall was an activist, a powerful presence, a mover and shaker, a thinker, a partner, a parent, a teacher, a potter and painter, a very special person. She is best remembered for the most public part of her legacy, La Mama Theatre, a Carlton icon.
She had the courage of her convictions. She came back from a trip to America with the intention of trying to start a coffee-theatre like La Mama in New York, which had so impressed her. So in 1967, when confronted by a 'To Let' sign being hammered up on 205 Faraday Street, Carlton, a student area with an interesting ethnic mix, she hired it for about $14 a week to house a theatre group which aimed to perform modern Australian plays. The building had started life as a printing workshop and then became an underwear and shirt factory, not a usual theatre space, but it met at least two requirements - it was cheap and small. The people she gathered together now read like a Who's Who of Australian theatre whose stories are well documented.
Betty established principles which the group of actors, playwrights and staff still follow: keep the space open and accessible, avoid debt, and stay within the community, all groups which were to amply reward her efforts. As Liz Jones, her colleague and successor, says, "La Mama has never been about grand ideas, it has always been a launching place for great minds and great ideas, and it has always been a place which allows all members of the community to have a say." As she pointed out it did not matter whether they were or are theatre people, indigenous people, itinerants, the unemployed, or street people. It was also designed to be affordable and intimate and, while Betty was no doubt pleased to be honoured by an Order of Australia in 1993, one has the feeling she saw it as a reward for all those who had worked with and supported her, in the special adventure which was, and is, La Mama.
Betty was also influential in the development of her husband Tim Burstall's film career and he was a part of the fertile creative scene that centred on La Mama. Their two sons, Dan and Tom are also involved in the film industry. They have much to be proud of.
Dr Judith Biddington
Book Launch Completes Successful Year for CCHG
On Saturday 17 November 2012 the Carlton Community History Group Inc launched their new publication Walking Along Rathdowne Street : 100 years of shopping, services and stories in North Carlton by Margaret Rich. As the acting president, Jeff Atkinson, commented, "What a fantastic book launch".
Jacki Fristacky, our new Mayor, long term Nicholls Ward councillor and CCHG patron made an interesting and thought provoking speech. However, it was very crowded. We had between 55 and 60 people crammed into the meeting room and had to turn others away, for which we apologise. We sold many books on the day and have since had to reprint 100 more copies. The Library has already sold out its initial stock, the local post office has agreed to sell the books and we have had orders from as far afield as Provence, Ireland and New Zealand. Margaret's research skills and her experience as a teacher has made what could have been a pedestrian list into an interesting read. The enthusiasm generated also reflects the community's involvement with the suburb , the street itself and its history. As we had hoped, this book has already generated more local history to add to our collection.
If you have any stories or photos about any part of Carlton we would appreciate you passing them on to us. It is a fascinating suburb, as are the people who have lived, and continue to live here. We want to preserve their contributions be they large or small. Contact us
Fancy Footwork at Carlton Hall
In 2012 Dancehouse celebrated 20 years of contemporary dance in North Carlton. The leading edge dance hub was established in June 1992 at Carlton Hall in Princes Street, formerly occupied by the Carlton Community Centre. Carlton Hall has a long association with dance, as a venue for social dances, dance classes and dance performance. But the most famous dance took place in 1877 between two political rivals, James Munro and John Curtain.1
Carlton Hall was built in February 1877, in controversial circumstances during the election campaign for the new seat of Carlton. James Munro, an avowed temperance advocate, stood against Carlton publican John Curtain. According to Michael Cannon in the Land Boomers, Munro's pro-publican opponents prevented him from hiring a hall in Carlton, so he countered their opposition by building his own hall in 14 days, at a cost of £2,000. The Burchett index confirms that James Munro registered his notice of intent to build a public hall in Reilly Street (later renamed Princes Street) on 10 February 1877. Carlton builder John Pigdon must have worked around the clock to have construction completed in time for Munro to address a meeting of electors on Monday 5 March 1877. But the claimed cost of £2,000 is in question. R.N. Henningham, in a letter to the editor of The Argus, refutes allegations that John Curtain denied Munro access to his hall in Drummond Street, and states a considerably lower construction cost of "£200 or £300" for Munro's new public hall. Was this amount closer to the actual cost of construction, or was it an attempt to diminish public sympathy for James Munro? In the end, the electorate decided in favour of Munro, who won the seat of Carlton by a narrow majority in May 1877. Four years later in September 1881 Carlton Hall, including its furniture and fittings, was sold for £1,755.2,3,4,5,6,7
James Munro honoured a pre-election promise in granting 2 years' free rent to the Carlton Mechanics' Institute, for establishment of a free reading-room, subscription library, gymnasium, and debating society. The Mechanics' Institute also collected rent revenue from tenants and other users of the hall. A separate court of petty sessions for Carlton was established in 1878, and Carlton Hall provided temporary premises until the new court house was built in Drummond Street. In keeping with its origins, Carlton Hall was home to several temperance organisations, friendly societies and masonic lodges, and served as a polling booth for state and municipal elections well into the 20th century.8,9
As a Melbourne City Council property, Carlton Hall was the focus of victory celebrations following the end of World War 2 in August 1945. With a critical housing shortage in the immediate post-war years, Carlton Hall and several other council properties offered overnight emergency accommodation for families evicted from their homes. In April 1947, the Carlton sub-branch of the RSL was granted a lease of Carlton Hall, at a rent of £260 per year. George Ward, who grew up in Henry Street, remembers following the Anzac Day march along Rathdowne Street to Carlton Hall. "Us kids would march behind and those who got to sit on the floor down the front were given food and drink." The RSL Carlton sub-branch remained at Carlton Hall until the late 1960s, when they moved to Louisville in Amess Street North Carlton.10,11,12,13
The Carlton Community Centre was established in the 1970s and offered community activities, school holiday programs and classes to residents of Carlton and North Carlton. Following the re-organisation of council boundaries in the 1990s, Carlton Hall was transferred from Melbourne City Council to its present owner, City of Yarra.
Notes and References:
1 Melbourne Times Weekly, 20 June 2012, p. 20
2 Cannon, Michael. The Land Boomers, Lloyd O'Neil, 1986, p. 243
3 Burchett Index, Reg. no. 7073, 10 Feb 1877
4 The Argus, 2 March 1877, p. 4
5 The Argus, 28 February 1877, p. 7
6 The Argus, 14 May 1877, p. 5
7 The Argus, 13 September 1881, p. 2
8 The Argus, 11 July 1878, p. 4
9 Building occupancy information sourced from Sands & McDougall and contemporary newspaper advertisements.
10 The Argus, 15 August 1945, p. 4
11 The Argus, 12 March 1946, p. 7
12 The Argus, 28 April 1947, p. 8
13 Ward, George. Henry Street and beyond
From the Pacific to Carlton
Did you see the TV show "The Pacific" when the soldiers came to Melbourne for their R & R? If you had, you would have seen US marine Robert Leckie visit his girl friend in a double storey house in Rathdowne Street. Then he visited his neighbour in a lovely double fronted house in Fenwick Street.
This program has been screened all around the world showing a little piece of Carlton.
La Porchetta Farewells Rocco Pantaleo
Rocco 'Rocky' Pantaleo, who died in a road accident on 26 March 2010 at the age of 53, will be remembered as an important force in the rejuvenation of the Rathdowne Street shopping strip between Curtain and Fenwick Streets, North Carlton. Shops at both ends of this block have over more than a century always survived economic and demographic changes, but a number of shops in the middle of the block became private dwellings as early as the 1930s. One such was 392 Rathdowne Street, out of commercial use for thirty years when in 1974 Santo Aiello and a partner opened Porchetteria, later called La Porchetta. According to newspaper reports, it was in a run-down condition when in 1985 it was taken over by Rocky Pantaleo, who had arrived in Australia as a young man of 21 and speaking no English less than ten years before. It was the first of his tremendously successful pizza restaurants which over the years expanded into a huge franchised business and four frontages in Rathdowne Street. The steady flow of diners is a mainstay to local shops of all kinds and local residents and long-term traders alike acknowledge the importance of Rocky Pantaleo's contribution to these Rathdowne Street shops.
Farewell Jack Ward
In 2009 one of our members, Jack Ward, died. The Carlton Community History Group will miss him for a variety of reasons. Jack was not only a really nice man, cheeky, friendly and always on time, he was passionately interested in North Carlton where he and his brother George and his younger sister Froney grew up. Half brothers Jack and George Ward and sister Froney lived in Fenwick St and later Henry St on the edges of the Rathdowne street shops. Together their experiences cover the time from Jack's birth in 1934 to the family's departure for Doncaster in 1966 some 32 years later when Froney was 12. Their memories record changes in the shops, businesses, and the characters and actions of the people who lived around them. Jack found us after looking at a number of history groups, and he and George came all the way from Glen Waverley and Croydon to attend our monthly meetings. They have been a source of a great deal of information.
Jack was influential in our Rathdowne Street project partly because of his persistence in wanting us to make a map of the shops. One day he stood up at a meeting and drew a startlingly accurate map of the shops in the area between Fenwick and Newry Streets. We copied that and it became the basis for some interviews with him and George supplemented by material from Froney. Suddenly the picture of Rathdowne Street was not only peopled with exotic, hard working Jews and Italians running businesses but well established, hard working, generous, and gregarious Australians whose community, lives and activities came to life through colloquial and somewhat less than politically correct anecdotes. That part of our history had somehow gone missing, perhaps because it might seem too ordinary. But history is more than great or extraordinary men and women. We will remember Jack fondly and will go on working with George and Froney as we know he would like us to do. Although he left school like many of his generation at 14, he obviously had a sharp mind and went on learning and contributing all his life. Local history would be poorer and less accurate without people like him. We thank him sincerely.
Some Women of Davis Street : 1891 and 2008
Why Women of Davis Street?
In 2008 the CCHG became aware of a chapter in They are but Women : The Road to Female Suffrage in Victoria, which looked at the lives of some women who lived in Davis Street who signed a petition in 1891 calling on the Victorian Government to grant votes to women. We acknowledge the contribution of that research and build on it to explore the similarities and differences between the lives of those women and some women who currently live in Davis Street. We know the petitioners wanted votes for women and we examine the attitudes of the contemporary women to the achievement of that goal.
The work also raises the question of when we should be celebrating the centenary of suffrage for Victorian women. Should it be when the legislation was finally passed by both houses of Parliament in November 1908, the granting of Royal Assent and gazetting of the legislation in March 1909 or the first state election when women actually exercised that right on 16 November 1911?
The Carlton Community History Group thinks we should celebrate them all.
We celebrated the passing of the legislation, in conjunction with the Yarra Council, in November 1908 with a performance by Wilma Farrow of The Immigrant's Friend and the Womens' Campaigner about the lives of Caroline Chisholm and Vida Goldstein, both ardent suffragists.
We are currently celebrating Royal Assent and the gazetting of the legislation with a small display tracing the development of the campaign in the Carlton Library.
We will celebrate again in 2011, 100 years after women first voted in a Victorian election. Did any of your forbears sign that petition? If so, can you tell us something about them? We have a list of all women in Carlton and North Carlton who did, but many others also come to the area later. They could form the basis of our celebration in 2011.
We also need to remember how easy it is to be confused about dates. Most of us believe that with Federation in 1901 women were granted the right to vote. In a sense that is true, but the first election for Federal Parliament was held in 1901 under state electoral laws, all of which were different and women who lived in Victoria, New South Wales, Tasmania and Queensland were not able to vote. We forget that in December 1908, after the suffrage legislation passed both houses of parliament an election was held in Victoria but women could not vote then either because the bill had not received Royal Assent. We also tend to forget that although after March 1909 women could vote they did not get a chance to do so until 1911 and could not stand for state parliament until May 1924.
In March 2009, more history has been made. The first woman has been elected as Premier of any state in Australia, Queensland. Our contemporary respondents will take heart from that result. But it is likely they will also be asking when Victoria will be making this kind of history?
CCHG Inc - March 2009
Photo: David Langdon
CCHG President Judith Biddington and Wilma Farrow
Home | News | About Us | Recollections | Street Names | Small Streets of Carlton | Carlton in the News | Crime in Carlton | Travelling in Carlton | Carlton in the War | Rathdowne Street | Images of Carlton | Publications | Membership | Meetings | Contact Us | Links